|
AN EXPLORATION
OF THE INFLUENCE OF COMPANY POLICY ON ETHICAL DECISION MAKING BY COMMUNITY
PHARMACISTS
Wingfield
J, Theophilou T, Bissell P. Nottingham School of Pharmacy, NG7 2RD, ( [email protected])
Introduction
Community pharmacists work in a commercial environment that must respond
to profit imperatives and consumer pressure. Few are owner-proprietors
1 and are therefore operating within organisational cultures set by others.
These cultures may be small and informal or of national proportions and
complexity. When individual pharmacists deal with ethical dilemmas at
pharmacy level, their options may be influenced by policies and procedures
that reflect values and priorities in company policy rather than needs
of the patient. This study, a final year pharmacy student project, sets
out to describe the nature of these dilemmas.
Methodology
A literature review revealed few studies that looked specifically at organisational
and commercial influences on ethical decision-making in community pharmacy.
To research this area, a focus group of five community pharmacists was
first established to allow understanding and comparison of participant's
beliefs and experiences in this area 2. Using material gained from this,
11 semi-structured interviews were carried out with a sample of local
community pharmacists. Key questions included "How does the owner's
or company policy affect how you deal with ethical issues?" and
clarification of how often these arise, what action is taken and how policy
is amended.
Findings
The focus group identified ethical issues arising under 5 themes: management
of inventory, controlling costs or preserving profit, responding to consumer
pressure, marketing and promotion methods and role clarification. Examples
of such ethical dilemmas included stocking of "borderline"
slimming products, reuse of patient's returned medicines, interruptions
and time pressure to serve more customers, "3 for 2" offers
on medicines and accountabilities of locums, employee pharmacists, line
and non-pharmacist managers. Subsequent interviews provided more examples
of activities within these themes and identified situations where company
policy was of considerable assistance to "front-line" pharmacists
in guiding their thinking in difficult areas such as supply of emergency
hormonal contraception.
Discussion
This was a very small study in a largely unexplored aspect of community
pharmacy practice. Further research is planned to more comprehensively
describe and conceptualise the influence of commercial and corporate environment
on the professional autonomy of community pharmacists. For pharmacy services,
this research suggests that company policy may provide opportunities to
foster a more supportive, service based culture and relieve some of the
immediate burden of ethical decision-making at the "front line",
although arguably this may compromise professional autonomy of the individual
pharmacist. The current community pharmacy contract rewards prescription
volume causing ethical anxieties over time available for patient counselling
and for safe practice. The purchase of medicines has become a transaction
in commodities responding to ordinary commercial incentives and creating
ethical dilemmas for those pharmacists who do not see medicines as "ordinary
articles of commerce".
References
1. Harania V, (1998) "Independents Day", Chemist and Druggist,
250 (14 Nov), 42-44
2. David L Morgan (1998) The Focus Group Handbook, Focus group kit1, Sage
publication, Chapters 1,2,7,8, p1-33, 55-71
Presented at the HSRPP Conference 2004, London
|